Salted Honey Pie

This Salted Honey Pie is not only my new favorite pie – it’s my favorite pie EVER! A BIG statement! The custard-based filling gets its amazing caramel flavor from brown sugar and honey. It’s absolutely delicious and so easy to make, it may become your new favorite too!

Salted Honey Pie - An easy custard pie that tastes like caramel and honey! So good!

Salted Honey Pie recipe

Salted Honey Pie

Back in July, I traveled to visit my friend Julianne to eat our way through the desserts of Portland. We had everything from donuts to cake to ice cream. We even had some pie.

One of the pies we tried was a Salted Honey Pie. Now I have to admit I didn’t think all that much of it when I first saw it. I wouldn’t even describe myself as a big honey person – or pie person for that matter. As you know I love my cake. But for some reason it called to me and I got a slice.

The first bite was pure bliss! I mean seriously. There was a lot of moaning involved. I have never been so into a pie in my life. It tasted like creamy salted caramel in a perfect pastry crust. And yet that description doesn’t even do it justice.

And while a straight caramel pie could be a bit overwhelming, this was honey pie that tasted like caramel. It managed to be sweet and amazing without being too much. Perfection. Just pure perfection. I had to find a way to make my own version.

Best Salted Honey PieFavorite Salted Honey Pie

My own version proved to not be the easiest task. The flavor and texture were so unique. I played around with different amounts of eggs – plus whole eggs vs just yolks. I played around with the amount of sugar and brown vs regular. I played around with the amount of cream and thus thickener. I even tried putting straight caramel sauce into one version. There was a good bit of pie.

Earlier versions of the pie were almost more like a chess pie. Heavy on the sugar, low on the cream. While the flavor was delicious, the texture of the pie wasn’t quite right. If you’ve ever had a chess pie, you know that it isn’t exactly creamy.

Ultimately I went with egg yolks over whole eggs to add to the creamy texture. I added a good bit of heavy whipping cream to have a nice custard-based pie, so there’s also cornstarch to help thicken things. Brown sugar also won out over white sugar and it definitely gives the pie it’s caramel flavor.

Easy Salted Honey PieBest custard pie - Salted Honey Pie

How to Make This Delicious Honey Pie

The cream, brown sugar, cornstarch and salt are cooked over the stove first. The melted brown sugar gives the caramel flavor and the cornstarch thickens the cream. You’ll notice it really start to thicken right before you temper the eggs. The honey and vanilla are added last and then the pie is baked.

The pie bubbles up a good bit in the oven and when it’s done cooking, it’ll still be relatively jiggly. The edges of the pie crust should start to brown and the top of the pie will have browned as well. The pie will thicken as it cools, both on the counter and in the fridge.

The final pie was TO DIE FOR! You guys! I’m not even messing with you – it’s amazing! The name doesn’t do it justice. It’s one of those things I wish I could give samples of through the computer screen so you could understand just how awesome it is and how you need to make it. If you like caramel, you will love this pie.

I took an earlier version to our church group and just about every week since then, one person in particular has told me how good it was. Then I took the finally version to the office and everyone was just as unsuspecting as I initially was at hearing about a Salted Honey Pie. One bite and I turned them into believers!

YOU HAVE TO MAKE IT! 🙂

Best custard pie - Salted Honey Pie


Read Transcript
For more great pie recipes, check out this Classic Pumpkin Pie, Apple Crumb Cheesecake Pie, and more!

You might also like

Coconut Cream Pie
Blueberry Crumb Cheesecake Pie
No Bake Pumpkin Pie in a Jar
Banana Cream Pie
Almond Joy Pie
Pina Colada Pie

Print
clock clock icon cutlery cutlery icon flag flag icon folder folder icon instagram instagram icon pinterest pinterest icon facebook facebook icon print print icon squares squares icon
Image of Salted Honey Pie
Recipe

Salted Honey Pie

  • Prep Time: 15 minutes
  • Cook Time: 40 minutes
  • Total Time: 55 minutes
  • Yield: 8-10 Slices 1x
  • Category: Dessert
  • Method: Oven
  • Cuisine: American

Description

This Salted Honey Pie is not only my new favorite pie – it’s my new favorite dessert! A BIG statement! The custard-based filling gets its amazing caramel flavor from brown sugar and honey. It’s so easy to make, it may become your new favorite too!


Scale

Ingredients

  • Refrigerated pie crust
  • 4 large egg yolks, lightly beaten
  • 2 1/2 cups (600ml) heavy whipping cream
  • 1 cup (144g) unpacked light brown sugar
  • 1/3 cup cornstarch, sifted
  • 1/2 tsp salt
  • 1/2 cup (120ml) honey
  • 2 tsp vanilla extract
  • Sea salt, optional

Instructions

1. Prepare the pie crust in a deep dish 8 inch pie pan, or a 9 inch pie pan, and set it in the fridge. Do not pre-bake it. Preheat the oven to 375 degrees.
2. Add the egg yolks to a large bowl. Set aside.
3. To make the filling, heat the heavy cream, brown sugar, cornstarch and salt in a medium saucepan on medium heat until it comes to a rolling boil, stirring regularly. It should start to thicken.
4. Once the mixture comes to a full boil, remove it from the heat.
5. Temper the eggs by adding a little bit of the cream mixture to the eggs and whisking, then adding a little more. Add the remaining cream mixture and stir until combined and smooth.
6. Add the honey and vanilla extract to the custard and stir until well combined.
7. Pour the mixture into the pie crust.
8. Bake the pie for 40-45 minutes. It will bubble up and start to brown on top.
9. Remove the pie from the oven. It will still be pretty jiggly. Set it on the counter to cool until it comes to room temperature. It will firm up as it sits.
10. Refrigerate the pie until it’s cold and fully firm.
11. Sprinkle the sea salt onto the pie and serve.

Keywords: honey pie, honey dessert, dessert with honey, honey recipe, honey cake recipe, homemade pie, pie recipe, easy pie recipe, best pie recipe

Enjoy!

Salted Honey Pie - An easy custard pie that tastes like caramel and honey! So good!

This post may contain affiliate sales links. Please read my disclosure policy.

Share a Comment

Have a question? Use the form below to submit your question or comment. I love hearing from you and seeing what you made!

Recipe rating

135 Comments
  1. So sad

    I hope you can tell me what I did wrong. The custard tasted sooooo amazing when I put it in the crust. I know because I was full contact, face in the bowl licking it was so good. But after baking, it was the most bitter pie I have ever tasted. I followed directions exactly. I used a local raw honey straight from the hive. Any idea what happened?

    1. Lindsay

      I haven’t ever heard that before and I’m not really sure what would cause it. I’m sorry to hear that happened though!

  2. Elissa

    I just made this pie over the weekend, and all I can say is WOW!! Easy to make and so, so delicious – everyone at my office was raving about it. I will definitely make this again and again!

  3. Lauren Thompson

    SO GOOD. I have been looking for a salted honey pie recipe, since I’m from Portland and have an equal obsession with the pie you mentioned. Thank you!! Would make again and again!

  4. Hannah Dunning

    Ever since I made this last year it has become a new favorite in my family. This year I used an oatmeal crust which was a big hit and went so well with the pie

  5. Gabrielle

    I made it, following the recipe exactly, for Thanksgiving for the first time! I had never tried a salted honey pie but your description made it irresistible. Everyone was shocked by how good it was, and my dad told me it was the best pie he had ever tasted. Only thing is that the crust, on the bottom especially, was not as crisp as I prefer it (nobody else seemed to mind, though)– do you think it would be ok to blind bake the pie crust, then fill it, covering the crust with foil for the second bake?

  6. Steph

    Such a great recipe – folks still rave about it and ask me to make at every opportunity. Paired with a homemade whiskey whipped cream and its a dream! I typically only have dark brown sugar in my cupboard and still great! I used store bought honey this time and it was good. I think I prefer local honey for a little more depth of flavor!

    1. Lindsay

      I love the sound of that whipped cream! So glad the pie has been such a hit! It’s definitely one of my all-time faves.

  7. Ann Smith

    Oh. My. Word. This pie is AMAZING! It has such a wonderful honey flavor and the texture is so smooth and silky. After filling the pie shell the hubby and I licked the bowl and pot clean, once it was cool of course. Definitely making this again. Thanks for sharing such a fantastic recipe.

  8. Roberta

    I highly recommend you try his pie.  Simply delicious!
    We left the salt off, personally I felt it didn’t need it.  So good.
    Also a easy bake,  I cheated with a store bought graham cracker crust.  Over the top 😋

  9. Carly

    Absolutely delicious. I do have one question though. When I baked this pie, I did not pre-bake the crust. I used a pillsbury prepared pie dough and put the custard filling into the raw pie crust. Although the filling of the pie was set and cooked through, beautifully browned on top, my crust was raw. 🙁 do you suggest I prebake the crust?

    1. Lindsay

      I really don’t know why the crust wouldn’t have baked thoroughly. I can’t imagine that it wasn’t cooked. You could certainly try pre-baking the crust. I’ve made this pie so many times and never had that happen, so I’m not sure.

  10. Tiffany

    If we were to make these as mini pies in a muffin tin, how long would you bake it? Also, what about your pecan pie the same way? Everyone loves this pie!

    1. Lindsay

      I’m so glad to hear that everyone loves it! I honestly haven’t made mini pies before so I’m not really sure what the time would be. I’m sorry!

  11. Millie R.

    Insanely delicious! I have never heard of honey pie until I saw it on a menu at a cocktail bar. I loved it so much, I decided to Google a recipe and came across yours. Not only was this easy to make, it came out beautiful! Will definitely be making this over and over again! Thank you!

Lindsay
About Lindsay

I'm a wife and mom to twin boys, a baby girl and a sweet black lab with a serious sweets addiction! Bring on the sugar!

Scripture I’m Loving

“Be joyful in hope, patient in affliction, faithful in prayer.” Romans 12:12