Browned Butter Pecan Layer Cake

This post may contain affiliate sales links. Please read my disclosure policy.

This Browned Butter Pecan Layer Cake has three layers of buttery vanilla cake filled with toasted pecans that are covered with a delicious browned butter frosting! It’s the perfect cake for the holidays!

Browned Butter Pecan Layer Cake

Browned Butter Pecan Layer Cake recipe

Browned Butter Pecan Layer Cake

Can you believe that it’s November already? The holidays are approaching fast. I mean, not to freak you out or anything, but Thanksgiving is two weeks from Thursday. I’m not sure I can even wrap my head around that. We will actually spend the holiday with my family in Charlotte this year though, so I guess that means the pressure isn’t entirely on me. 🙂

We are getting into one of my favorite times of year – the holidays. Not only do I love the food and all the vacation days off, but I also love the time spent with family, slowing down a bit and being thankful for all that surrounds me and all that has happened during the year.

And this year we have so much to be thankful for. The hubs’ job has been going well, I released a cookbook, Simply Beautiful Homemade Cakes, and (breaking news!) I’m leaving my other job to blog full-time starting in December. Not to mention so many other wonderful things that we take for granted every day. Ultimately it’s the seemingly little things that we should be most thankful for.

Best Browned Butter Pecan Layer CakeBest Browned Butter Pecan Cake

One thing I totally take for granted is cake, since I’ve pretty much always got some in our house. But you know I love it and this cake is no exception.

The cake layers are a moist, buttery vanilla cake spotted with toasted pecans. The flavor of the cake alone is delicious. The pecans add a whole other level of awesome. Before adding them to the cake batter though, they are tossed with butter and brown sugar and toasted. Don’t skip this step! The flavor of the cake is so much better with the pecans toasted versus un-toasted. If you’ve never toasted pecans, all you need to do is put them in the oven on a cookie sheet for about 5 to 7 minutes until they’ve browned a bit and you can smell them. A wonderful way to make your house smell delicious and like the holidays have arrived!

The cake layers are frosted with my new favorite frosting. It begins with browned butter, which is heavenly and lends a caramel-y flavor to the frosting that pairs so well with the toasted pecans. Of course I used Challenge Butter, which is such a wonderful, good quality butter. And browned butter is just as it sounds – butter that is browned right on your stove top. The frosting recipe uses a good bit of browned butter so it takes a bit of time to brown, but you really just melt the butter and allow it to brown. It’ll get a little foamy as it cooks, but eventually the foam will subside and you’ll be done.

The butter is chilled until it’s firm again and then you can use it in your frosting! I love it! The full finished pecan layer cake is super moist and delicious!

Easy Browned Butter Pecan Layer CakeFavorite Browned Butter Pecan Cake

And in the spirit of the season and being thankful, Challenge Dairy is giving back. They are joining forces with UNICEF to fight and raise awareness of the childhood malnutrition crisis – which results in the unnecessary loss of nearly three million young lives a year. To do that, every recipe pinned from Challenge Butter’s “2016 Pin a Recipe, Feed a Child” pinterest board will result in a meal being donated to UNICEF for a child in need. Challenge Dairy hopes to provide up to 75,000 means to UNICEF, so let’s help them make this a reality! Here’s the pin for this recipe, if you’d like to pin that.

I hope you’re able to hop over and pin a recipe (or two!) and give this delicious Browned Butter Pecan Layer Cake a try! You won’t regret either!

Browned Butter Pecan Layer Cake decoratedBrowned Butter Pecan Layer Cake slice

clock clock icon cutlery cutlery icon flag flag icon folder folder icon instagram instagram icon pinterest pinterest icon facebook facebook icon print print icon squares squares icon
slice of Browned Butter Pecan Layer Cake

Browned Butter Pecan Layer Cake

  • Author: Lindsay
  • Prep Time: 20 minutes
  • Cook Time: 30 minutes
  • Total Time: 50 minutes
  • Yield: 12-14 Slices
  • Category: Dessert
  • Method: Oven
  • Cuisine: American


This Browned Butter Pecan Layer Cake has three layers of buttery vanilla cake filled with toasted pecans that are covered with a delicious browned butter frosting! It’s the perfect cake for the holidays!



  • 1/4 cup (56gsalted Challenge butter, melted
  • 2 1/4 cups (370g) finely chopped pecans
  • 2 tbsp light brown sugar, loosely packed


  • 3/4 cup (168gunsalted Challenge butter, room temperature
  • 1 1/2 cups (310g) sugar
  • 1 cup (231g) sour cream, room temperature
  • 1 tbsp vanilla extract
  • 5 large eggs, room temperature
  • 3 cups (390g) all purpose flour, preferably sifted
  • 4 tsp baking powder
  • 3/4 tsp salt
  • 1 cup (240ml) milk, room temperature
  • 2 tbsp (30ml) water, room temperature


  • 2 1/4 cups (504gsalted Challenge butter, room temperature
  • 1 1/4 cups (237g) shortening
  • 10 cups (1150g) powdered sugar
  • 6 tbsp (90ml) water or milk



1. Preheat the oven to 350°F (176°C). Line a cookie sheet with parchment paper or silicone baking mat.
2. Combine the melted butter, pecans and brown sugar in a medium sized bowl and toss to coat.
3. Spread the pecans evenly onto the cookie sheet and bake for 5-7 minutes, or until toasted.
4. Set pecans aside to cool.


5. Prepare three 8 inch cake pans with parchment paper circles in the bottom and grease the sides. Leave the oven at 350°F (176°C).
6. In a large mixing bowl, cream the butter and sugar together until light in color and fluffy, about 3-4 minutes. Do not skimp on the creaming time.
7. Add the sour cream and vanilla extract and mix until well combined.
8. Add the eggs one at a time, mixing until combined after each. Scrape down the sides of the bowl as needed to be sure all ingredients are well incorporated.
9. Combine the dry ingredients in a separate bowl, then combine the milk and water in a measuring cup.
10. Add half of the dry ingredients to the batter and mix until well combined. Add the milk mixture and mix until well combined. Add remaining dry ingredients and mix until well combined. Scrape down the sides of the bowl as needed to be sure all ingredients are well incorporated.
11. Gently stir 1 cup of the toasted pecans into the batter.
12. Divide the batter evenly between the cakes pans and bake for about 24-26 minutes, or until a toothpick comes out with a few crumbs.
13. Remove the cakes from the oven and allow to cool for about 2-3 minutes, then remove to cooling racks to cool completely.


14. Melt 2 cups of butter in a saucepan over medium heat. It’s best to use a light colored pan so that you can see the butter browning. Whisk the butter occasionally so that it cooks evenly.
15. Cook the butter until turns a nice toasty brown. It will foam up at first, particularly since this is a good bit of butter, but it will eventually subside and you’ll have browned butter. Some of the brown bits may separate, but that’s ok. Once the butter has browned, pour it into a heat-proof bowl and set it in the fridge to cool completely.
16. Bring the butter back to room temperature, then add it to a large mixer bowl with the additional 1/4 cup of butter and the shortening. Beat until smooth.
17. Slowly add about half of the powdered sugar and mix until smooth.
18. Add 4-5 tablespoons of water and mix until smooth.
19. Slowly add the remaining powdered sugar and mix until smooth.
20. Add the remaining water, if needed, and mix until smooth.


21. Use a large serrated knife to remove the domes from the top of the cakes so that they’re flat. Place the first cake on a serving plate or a cardboard cake round.
22. Spread about 1 cup of frosting evenly on top of the cake, then top the frosting with 3-4 tablespoons of the remaining toasted pecans.
23. Add the second layer of cake, another cup of frosting and 3-4 tablespoons of pecans.
24. Top the cake with the remaining layer and frost the cake. Refer to my tutorial for frosting a smooth cake, if needed.
25. Pipe swirls of frosting around the top edge of the cake and press the remaining pecans into the sides of the cake and sprinkle some over the top. Store the cake in an airtight container. Cake is best for 2-3 days.


  • Serving Size: 1 Slice
  • Calories: 1194
  • Sugar: 94.3 g
  • Sodium: 211.3 mg
  • Fat: 77.3 g
  • Carbohydrates: 121.3 g
  • Protein: 10.2 g
  • Cholesterol: 179.4 mg

Keywords: pecan dessert, vanilla cake, vanilla cake recipe, best vanilla cake recipe, browned butter frosting, layer cake, layer cake recipe, homemade vanilla cake

Filed Under:


Browned Butter Pecan Layer Cake! Buttery pecan cake with browned butter frosting! So good!

Share a Comment

Have a question? Use the form below to submit your question or comment. I love hearing from you and seeing what you made!

Recipe rating 5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

  1. Keyla

    Admito que todas tus recetas son fabulosas 🤩!!!! Estoy en Venezuela y no se encuentra crema agria acá¿cuál puede ser el mejor sustituto? ¿ yogurt?

  2. Kara

    I tried to skim the comments to see if you have been asked this before and I didn’t see that you had. I am sorry if I missed it. Have you used this cake recipe to make cupcakes? I was wondering how many it would make if you had. Thanks.

    1. Lindsay

      I’m so glad you enjoy it! I would imagine it would be fine as a sheet cake. If you are making it as a 9 x 13, I would reduce the baking temperature to 325.

  3. Megan

    Am I really supposed to use 10 cups of powdered sugar for the frosting!? I’ve never ever used that much before and i am scared lol

    1. Lindsay

      It is correct. It is a decorator-style buttercream, so it is thick. I also tend to use a good bit of frosting based on how I frost a cake. But if you tend to have a thinner layer of frosting on your cakes, feel free to reduce the overall amount of frosting.

  4. Key

    This was a very good cake I made it with cream cheese frosting instead which was lovely. Everyone liked it. My only quarrel was that the edges turned out kind of dry and the cake was denser than I prefer. I made it in a rush but would like to dissect how to make it better next time. I will add I did like your weights being accurate, I weighed most of the ingredients and it turned out fine. Thanks for a solid recipe!

    1. Lindsay

      I’m glad you enjoyed it! If the edges were dry, it may have been a little over-baked. And this cake is a little denser, so that seems like it was probably correct.

    1. Lindsay

      I haven’t tried buttermilk to be able to say for sure but it’s probably fine. Heavy cream is fine in the frosting.

  5. LJ

    I made this cake and it is absolutely delicious! Can this also be made as a pound cake or do you have a recipe for a browned butter pecan pound cake with a butter pecan glaze?

    1. Lindsay

      I’m so glad you enjoyed it! I haven’t tried baking it in a Bundt pan to say for sure, so you could give it a try. I do not have a pecan flavored pound cake recipe.

    1. Lindsay

      You can browned the butter for the cake but you may want to brown a little bit extra so you still have the same amount of butter after it’s been browned.

  6. Amber

    I have made this recipe several times and have to say it’s a family favorite. I save it for special occasions, though, because I really do not like baking. Most of my attempts turn out poorly – seriously I somehow mess up boxed cake mix and can frosting! But every time I make this cake it turns out perfectly! The taste is amazing, and I receive compliments and people asking for the recipe. It’s better than any bakery cake you could buy. Thank you so much for making me a super star baker!

  7. Pam

    Well mine wasn’t as pretty as yours but I am calling this one a Pinterest win. The cake was delicious and easier than I thought it would be. Everyone loved it!!!!
    Thank you for the lovely recipe.

  8. Jessica

    I’ve made this several times, everyone loves it. My sister makes it now too! The only thing I don’t do is the browned butter, I just do a cream cheese frosting. This cake is AMAZING! 

  9. Summer LaMoureaux

    First off, I’m NOT a baker, I’m a cook. Love to cook but loath baking. I don’t have the patience and measuring seems like a hassle to me. That’s why I love cooking, I just have a natural knack for it. I decided to embark on this cake for my mom and husbands birthday. That’s a gift in itself fir them. They know how much I hate baking. This cake is freaking amazing. It’s beautiful (not my version because I don’t have the frosting skills)! The frosting is amazing and the candied pecans are to die for. I added just a hint of cinnamon to mine. I read a lot of comments, from experienced bakers saying the measurements were off… I didn’t have that issue at all. Mind you this is coming from someone who hates to take the time to measure. Though there are a lot of steps involved I found it very easy to follow. I made this over two days to break up the monotony. I made the brown butter and cakes day 1. Day 2 made the frosting and decorated. This helped my ADHD. We are eating tonight so we haven’t tried it but I did lick and taste my way throughout the process and it’s all amazing.  Find this easy for non-bakers, like me, just break it up over a few days and you’ll survive. I followed everything to the T, even the teams of butter. The only change I made was a dash of cinnamon to the pecans. Cheers to you for creating an amazing cake. A cake I can be proud of and that was worth my time!!!  

  10. Cynthia

    It looked so delicious! I do something wrong! My pecans keep sinking to the bottom when baked. Would you be able do a step-by-step video of this recipe? Thank you.

  11. Brenda Milcetic

    Hi Lindsay,
    Do I store this cake in the fridge or on the counter? It looks amazing and I am wanting to make this for my mom’s 81st birthday. Thank you and God bless,

  12. Lisa

    Hi, this cake looks amazing and I am going to try your recipe. However, my question is off the wall. I want to know where you got the cake stand from. I love it!

  13. Jennifer

    This is a beautiful cake! I made this today and it came out gorgeous. I used 3 9 inch cake pans, the layers are a little thinner but today finding things not so easy so I made due. I used Irish Butter and thought it great. I did not use the frosting recipe because I just can’t do that shortening thing but I do understand why you would but I don’t want my friends to eat that so I found another browned butter butter cream recipe and I really liked it. All in all a real winner.

  14. Stacey

    I made this cake last night. It’s a very good cake!! However, the ingredients call for entirely too much powdered sugar in the frosting. It made the frosting so sweet that it overpowered the taste of the actual cake. Next time I’m going to cut that and use maybe 4 1/2 cups of powdered sugar instead.

  15. Karen

    My wedding in 2005 had a butter pecan layer and a strawberry layer. Every year I usually do a strawberry cake but 15 year I searched and luckily landed on your recipe! When I saw brown butter I was all in! Paula Dean has a brown butter icing spiced oatmeal cookie that I take to all cookie exchanges so I had made that before. But I never did refrigerate it and bring to room temp. When I saw all that black stuff (burn flavor crystals) I freaked out and I almost threw that settlement away!!! I am so glad I didn’t! Also the toasted pecans were heavenly on their own. In fact I still think about that part. I made this cake in June to the T. I did use swans cake flour though. Today I want to make a pumpkin crunch cake I plan to use your method of toasting the pecans I cut the recipe and added cinnamon to the pecans and it definitely messed something up. Back to the drawing board. But this recipe I bet I gained 5 lbs! LOL It is Rich but great for a special occasion. I posted on my FB page and used my new icing tools and people went nuts,

  16. Susan

    I baked this cake this week for my sister in law’s birthday. 
    I really should have read through the reviews first because there are a couple of things I would have changed and will change up – mainly with the frosting. 
    The cake itself will be my go-to cake for vanilla cake.  The cake, although dense, is moist. When building a cake, this is exactly the kind of cake you want – it will hold its shape very well. And the flavour is bar-none one of the best vanilla cakes I’ve ever had!  Well done!
    However, with regards to the frosting, there is way too much icing sugar. I will next time be cutting that in half and starting from there…adding more as needed. I’ll also be cutting the shortening out all together – replacing it with butter. It makes for a very hard to pipe frosting as the shortening makes it very hard to handle when using smaller tips. Shortening doesn’t break down as easily as butter.  As well, the flavour of an all-butter frosting will beat out a shortening blend any day for me.  I also should have added more cream than I did.  But then I used whipping cream (my go to in frostings) instead of milk. I find it usually gives a creamier texture which is so nice. But in hindsight, cream is thicker than milk and I should have added more. 
    I loved the flavour of the browned butter and the specks it created in the frosting.  So beautiful!
    For the pecans I used the dark brown Demerara sugar to candy them – oh my goodness such an amazing flavour to add to the pecans!

    Thank you for sharing this great recipe.  

    All in all a great go-to for a Butter Pecan Cake! 

  17. Erika

    Soo excited to try this recipe out! Just wondering, can I make this cake with 9″ pans? If not, I’m having my weekly shopping trip tomorrow so I can purchase some. Thanks!

  18. Victoria Camron

    My husband asked for a cake inspired by chocolate chip cookies. So I used your recipe and added semi-sweet chocolate chips. He loves it! I had to “make my own” powdered sugar for part of the frosting, which turned out a bit gritty. But I will definitely keep this in my repotoire.

  19. June

    May I ask what flour brand you use or recommend using? Thank you! I’m so excited to try this recipe based on all the positive reviews! 

    1. Lindsay

      I have used a storebrand flour, gold metal, white lily and Pillsbury before and typically don’t notice a huge difference between them in the end product. White lily has a lovely texture to it though.

  20. Sheila

    I was asked to make a cake for a benefit auction, and decided to make this one. I made it exactly like the recipe, and it turned out perfectly. Luckily, I knew the guy who bought it, and he saved me a piece. This is my new favorite cake, and I really don’t even like pecans. That’s how good it is! And, it raised $600 at the auction!!! 

  21. Milia Staggs

    Made this cake a few times and it is so good! Like one of the best cakes I’ve ever made. So thank you for that! Secondly, I have a friend who is obsessed with pecan… Do you think it would be overkill to make this cake but fill it with your pecan pie filing from your your pecan pie cake recipe? Or do you think the flavors still work?

    1. Lindsay

      I’m so glad you enjoyed it! If she really loves pecans, it shouldn’t be overkill. I think this cake is a little more dense than the other one, but I would think they should go together fine.

  22. Kaley

    I made this for my husband’s early Thanksgiving potluck at work. Everyone loved it (including myself, I made 1.5x the recipe so I could have some all for me haha)! I did a lattice border on the top layer and sprinkled the remaining chopped pecans in the center to imitate a pecan pie 😉 

    1. Lindsay

      I’m so sorry for the trouble! There was an issue today that affected thousands of sites – mine included. It looks like it’s been resolved, so you should be able to access it here now. Sorry about that!

  23. Eric

    Awesome cake but would just cut down on the icing sugar in the frosting was a little too sweet. I cut mine down by 4 cups.

    1. Ginny

      I am making this cake for an office baking competition. I baked the cakes tonight, but I have one question/concern. I followed the directions very carefully, but my cakes turned out very thin. Like each layer is not even an inch tall. Seems like they didn’t really rise at all. Any suggestions?

      1. Lindsay

        It’s hard to say exactly but there are few common things that could cause that. One is not fully creaming the butter and sugar. You want to let your mixer run for a full 3 to 4 minutes so that it incorporates enough air into the batter. You could also check your leavening agent to make sure that is still good. Also, be sure not to over mix the batter at the end when you add the flour. Mix just until everything comes together.

  24. Ana Rivas

    This cake was amazing! I made a couple changes on the amount of shortening in the frosting and the amount of powdered sugar but still tasted great! Thanks for this recipe! Made it for my mother’s birthday.:)

  25. Elym M Hernández

    Hello Lindsay !! I want to try this cake so bad y looks and sound so yummy, but I need to be clear before I put all my ingredients at risk, the flour needs to be sifted before or after I measured? 
    I’ll be waiting for your response, thank you very much in advance ????????????????

    1. Lindsay

      I don’t usually sift my flour, I just give it a good stir. I also use weight to measure to ensure accuracy. I might try stirring it, measuring, then sifting.

  26. Amanda

    I’ve never had browned butter frosting before and I have seriously been missing out, because this was amazing! I made it twice (both times made a 4-layer 6in cake) and everyone -kids and adults- loved it. Thanks!

  27. Kam

    Has anyone else run into this problem?
    I’m an experienced baker. I followed the recipe exactly & used high quality salted butter, whole milk, and sifted the AP flour, salt, and (fresh) baking powder. No issues there. All ingredients were mixed using a KitchenAid stand mixer and baked in 8” NordicWare aluminum round pans. I googled to confirm that an 8” pan holds 4 cups of batter.
    However, the batter only yielded 8 cups, filling 2 8” pans, no where near enough for 3. The layers were incredible dense, thought moist. Even looking at the ingred list, how would this possibly yield 12 cups? No one else has mentioned this problem. What could’ve happened? Also, while delicious, the cake was very, very sweet. Living in Texas, I understand just how much southerners love a sweet dessert, but I thought it should be mentioned somewhere within the comments, for those that would like to lighten it up a bit. On their own, the buttercream and brown sugar pecans are amazing, but a little much when combined. 
    If anyone can shed light on what might have happened with my batter, I would love your insight. TY!

    1. Lindsay

      Hi Kam! Although an 8 inch cake pan may hold 4 cups of batter, you do not need to fill it all the way. Just divide the batter evenly between the cake pans, however much that ends up being. This cake is a little denser than some, but if you filled your cake pans too much, you could have ended up with an even denser cake.

  28. Nina

    Hi Lindsay,
    Your presentation is so beautiful every time! You had recommended this cake to me when i asked you about a recipe for Thanksgiving, and I made it for a party i was invited to. This cake is so, so good! Everyone, and I mean EVERYONE loved it! Even the little kids at the party nearly licked their plates clean. There was no cake left afterwards.

    The cake was nice and light, and the frosting was to die for! And everything combines so beautifully. Thank you once again for sharing your amazing recipes with us.

  29. Cate

    I made this cake with plugra brand butter, which has more butterfat than challenge.  I used a lower protein all purpose flour, a commercial brand comparable to Gold Medal.  I was skeptical about using all purpose flour in a cake, and my hesitation proved correct, the cake is dense, heavy and on the dry side.  Cake flour is really a must for a light airy cake.  

    I think it’s more suitable as a muffin recipe than a cake recipe.

  30. Dave Abell

    Good afternoon Miss Lindsay.  I am an over the road truck driver and as such prone to long periods of time away from home. When I am at home, I like to set aside ONE day to unwind. I usually do this by composing dinner along with a bread accompanyment or some kind of rolls or biscuits. Of course, you have to have dessert. I am REALLY looking forward to baking this beautiful cake over the Christmas holiday. Thank you SO MUCH for taking the time to share these with us

  31. Ruhee M.

    Hi Lindsay – this recipe looks amazing! Anything with brown butter is mouthwatering. Do you think the frosting would be just as delicious on a chocolate cake?

    1. Lindsay

      I certainly think it could be. I like it with more of a vanilla cake because the chocolate doesn’t compete with it, but it’d probably be fine.

  32. Nik

    I made this for my boyfriend’s birthday and we really loved it! The frosting is soooo good. It tastes just like ice cream. Next time I will use unsalted butter in the frosting. I found it to be a little salty but it was literally just the smallest bit. I did not use Challenge brand so that is the most likely reason why. Thank you so much for the recipe!!!

    1. Lindsay

      Did you use all butter for the frosting, instead of part shortening? If so, I agree with you completely that all salted butter would be too much. I would suggest half salted and half unsalted, or just using all unsalted and adding your own salt to it. A little salt is nice for flavor. 🙂 Glad you enjoyed the cake!

  33. Princess

    Hello Lindsay I have a request to make this cake in a 2 layer (10 inch) so my question is can or should this recipe be double to make a 2 layer (10 inch) cake? Would you suggest I cut both cakes in half and fill with icing also…

    1. Lindsay

      I haven’t made it as a 10 inch, but that would seem right to double it. Making into four layers is certainly an option if you want to add more frosting between the layers.

  34. Princess

    I am making this cake today, but I have a question..The Grocery Stores in my area do not sale Challenged Butter, and I have always used Unsalted Butter when I bake, so how much salt should I add to the Butter where it calls for Salted Butter or would it be ok to go with out..Thanks for sharing as always I enjoy making your sweet treats..

    1. Lindsay

      You don’t have to use Challenge butter, it’s just the brand I use. The recipe calls for unsalted butter in the cake. In the other parts, I would just add it to taste. You won’t need much for the pecans.

      1. Princess

        Hey Lindsay I made the cake, and it was Delicious…I was worried about making Brown Butter, but I did a great job, and my Frosting was great; as I am still learning how to make Butter Creams/Frosting…I used Butter milk instead of sour cream…I love love your recipes thanks for sharing…

  35. Carmella

    Hi! I absolutely love your site. I actually have someone who wants a butter Pecan cake this week but when I saw your cake I just have to try it. I have a question though can you substitute sour cream for something else

    1. Lindsay

      Sure you can. Some people use yogurt. You could also try replacing it with additional milk. I haven’t it with either, but those *should* be ok substitutions.

  36. Renee Ragoonanan

    This looks wonderful. Do you think it’s possible to substitute Margarine for butter in the cake recipe when creaming the butter and sugar? 

  37. Gail

    Made this for my son’s birthday. He LOVES butter pecan cake and it’s what he asks for every year. This is the first one I’ve made that wasn’t dry! Everyone loved it! This will be a yearly tradition for sure.

  38. Jessica

    I finally got around to making this delectable cake. When I was making the frosting however it separated and didn’t look fluffy at all? What could I have done wrong?

    1. Lindsay

      It’s possible it had to do with the temperature of the browned butter. If it was too soft still, maybe that is what caused it. You could try refrigerating the butter until it’s nice and firm first.

  39. Kay

    Beautiful! But did you forget to list pecans within the icing? How have you achieved the brown speckled appearance on the outside?

    1. Lindsay

      Thanks Kay! No – it’s from the browned butter, not pecans. Browned butter has little brown specks like that.

  40. Sara Richelson

    I made this and I can’t wait to eat it, but I have a LOT of frosting left. Like 2 cups. Does it keep? For how long do you think?

    1. Lindsay

      I’m certainly a bit more heavy-handed with frosting than some. 🙂 Yes, it keeps just fine. I’d say refrigerated for 1-2 weeks, but you could even freeze it for maybe a month.

  41. Vincent Cobb

    I’ve been hypnotized by all your scrumptious looking recipes and now I want to go attack my refrigerator. I do have a question though: Why do you use salted butter in your recipes? I was always told to use unsalted butter. Is that just a cooking myth?

    1. Lindsay

      Thanks Vincent! Not a myth really, but there isn’t necessarily a right or wrong way in my opinion. Just a preference. You’ll actually find it both ways on the site. The reason for using unsalted butter is to control the amount of salt that is added. With salted butter, there’s no need to add additional salt because it’s already in the butter. I find that the salted butter I use is just fine for salt content. However, if you’re sensitive to salt, you can definitely use unsalted butter and add your own salt. I hope that helps!

      1. Taylor

        Hello. Could I make this cake and then refrigerate it for a day before eating it ? Will it still be fresh ?

      2. Lindsay

        Yes, it’ll be fine made a day ahead. If you refrigerate it, I just suggest serving at room temperature.

  42. Grace

    I made this today to test run it before thanksgiving and all I can say is “OMG! Soooo good!” I took a few pieces to my parents and my dad couldn’t stop talking about how good it is! This cake is so a keeper for the recipe stash!

  43. Pam M.

    Hey Lindsey,  The cake sounds wonderful!  Would there be any problem with substituting butter for the shortening in the icining?

  44. Alma Vorrei

    i made this for the first time the other day and thought it was the best thing on the planet. the frosting is to die for. they ate it at work so fast i only got 1 piece.

  45. Melissa Howell

    Hi Lindsay! I just found your blog (via Lisa at Wine and Glue). Your cakes look SPECTACULAR! I’m putting your book on my wishlist for Christmas!

About Lindsay

I'm a wife and a mom to twin boys and a baby girl! And I've got a serious sweets addiction! Bring on the treats!

Scripture I’m Loving

“Come to me, all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you and learn from me, for I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will find rest for your souls.” Matthew 11:28-29