Who loves cookie dough? I know I’m a fan. And one of the best ways to eat it – other than straight out of the bowl as you’re making cookies – is in ice cream. So to crank it up a notch, I made Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pie. And my goodness, it is good!
What you see here is actually the second version. Version 2.0, if you will. The first one I made had a straight up cookie dough crust. Like literally about a quarter inch thick layer of cookie dough at the bottom. Sounds amazing, right? The only problem was that frozen cookie dough can be tough to get a fork through. And even though I was like, BRING IT ON! It didn’t really work out to be all that much fun to have to work so hard to take a bite.
So I switched it up a bit and now we have an oreo crust. I love me some ores too. And now this pie is perfect! I’m trying not to open the freezer so that I can forget it’s there. I just want to face plant in it.
It’s pretty easy to make too. And to make it even easier you could use a store bought cookie dough instead of making your own – though the one posted below is quite awesome. And to be honest, I’m not sure if the store bought cookie dough is technically “safe to eat” but the one below is definitely a safe no-egg, no-bake cookie dough.
So which ever way you decide to go with the cookie dough, once you have it made (or bought), you want to break it up into little balls of dough that are between 1/2 and 3/4 inch in diameter. I actually made my balls closer to 3/4 inch and then cut them either in half or fourths after they were frozen. This step is kind of important because if the balls are too big, they are also tough to get a fork through. Smaller, bite-size balls are best.
Once you have your dough into balls, freeze them. This will allow them to be mixed into the ice cream mixture without getting broken or messed up.
The next step is to make the oreo crust. Crush about 15 oreos. I like to use my food processor – it’s quick and gets the job done right. Add in the melted butter and press the crust into the bottom of the pie pan. You can have it going up the sides, or stick with a thicker crust on the bottom only.
To make the ice cream filling, mix together the cream cheese, sugar and dark brown sugar. Add the cool whip and mix. Then stir in the mini chocolate chips with a spatula and gently fold in about 3/4 of the frozen cookie dough balls. You’ll want to hold onto the rest of the cookie dough to garnish the top of the pie.
Pour the ice cream mixture into the oreo crust. Top with remaining cookie dough and mini chocolate chips. Allow to freeze and then devour!
Ingredients
Instructions
Cookie dough recipe modified from Sally’s Baking Addiction.
Enjoy!!
This post is linked to Crazy for Crust’s Pi Day Pie Party 2013, Pint Sized Baker, Inside BruCrew Life, Lady Behind The Curtain, Buns In My Oven, Ashley’s Dandelion Wishes, Kitchen Meets Girl, Chocolate, Chocolate and More, Lil Luna, Love Bakes Good Cakes, Mandy’s Recipe Box, The Mandatory Mooch, What’s Cooking Love? and Chef In Training.
Want more?
Snickers Peanut Butter Brownie Ice Cream Cake
Baileys Hot Chocolate Ice Cream Pie
No Bake Nutella, Peanut Butter and Marshmallow Fluff Pie
Hi, I'm Lindsay! I'm a wife and puppy mom with a serious sweets addiction! Bring on the sugar!
oh this looks DIVINE!! i love me some cookie dough!
Thanks Carrie! It’s as good as it looks too
This sounds amazing!
Wow! This is one amazing pie! Love cookie dough and this idea of adding it to a pie!
Thanks Anna! It’s pretty indulgent, but so good
OH MY GOSH. This looks beyond amazing. The pretties ice cream pie I’ve ever seen! And so full of cookie dough! It’s a must make. I love frozen pies like this.
And cookie dough anything is the best, right?! 
Thanks Sally! I tried to pack in as much cookie dough as I could. Love that stuff!
Holy COW! Yes please, I’ll take 4 slices.
Stopping by from the Pi Day Party..thank you for a great no-egg cookie dough recipe. I’ve been looking for one. I’d totally be hiding this in the freezer too.
Pinning!
Kristin
Thanks Kristin! It’s definitely a good one! Thanks for stopping by!
if you use sore bought cookie dough, how much do you think is required?
I haven’t actually used store bought dough for this before, but I would think one package (about 1 lb) should be enough. You don’t want the pie to be too overloaded or it could be difficult to eat.
Looks fantastic! Was wondering if pressed for time a premade oreo crust would work?
Definitely.
I will be making this next weekend for my son’s birthday! He loves cookie dough ice cream!
Great!
Happy Birthday to your son!
The whip that I use is not whipped, and then I whip it up into whip cream. How does that translate into cool whip? Is cool whip already whipped?
Cool Whip is already whipped, but it also has different ingredients than whipping cream (if that’s what you use). I’m not sure that you could substitute the cool whip for whipped cream made from whipping cream in this particular recipe.
What about a bashed chocolate chip cookie crust instead of oreo? I might try using store bought dough just fir that then make the rest.
the pie looks delicious!
Haha baked not bashed… Silly fingers.
Hi Megan! I actually did that the first time around and ended up changing it to an oreo crust because it was so hard to cut through the frozen cookie. Mine was pretty thick though – maybe if you had a thinner cookie it’d be better. Either way you go, it should be great!
Hello! How much butter is called for in the cookie dough? Thanks!
Ha! Nevermind! I need my glasses on!
What are the normal measurements? I want to make it but I have no idea how to put this together…
Here is a link to a page that has a great tool for converting measurements: http://www.dianasdesserts.com/index.cfm/fuseaction/tools.measures I hope that helps!
Oh my word – that looks amazing! I made my own version of a cookie dough ice cream pie a few years ago (http://smallhomebigstart.blogspot.ca/2011/01/cookie-dough-ice-cream-pie.html) and I totally get what you mean about the cookie dough layer getting hard to put a fork through. This is the perfect solution – you still get cookie dough in each bite, but without the struggle. I’ll definitely be making this next time
Thanks Amanda! Yours looks delicious too
Dear Lindsay,
You are a genius. I want to eat every last crumb of this pie. That is all.
Haha, thanks Nicole!
I love your ice cream cakes so much. I have made 5 different ones now and my favourite is a toss up between this and the bailey’s chocolate one. I keep taking them into work and have become very popular. People keep saying I am a good baker but I tell them I can follow a recipe but you are the genius behind the cakes I am making. Thank you so much for sharing your recipes.
I think I would like a slice of this pie as well as one slice each of the three other cakes/pies pictured! Yummy!!!
Thanks Terry!!
Oh my goodness…. this pie looks HEAVENLY!!!!! It sounds absolutely amazing!!!!
Thanks Maria!
Found your recipe on Pinterest….and it looks amazing! Who doesn’t love cookie dough or icecream, right?! That being said I have an allergy to cream cheese (weird, I know) so wondering what I could maybe substitute and still get the right consistency? Thanks!
I’ve actually been wanting to try replacing the cream cheese with Greek yogurt. That could be good – and healthy.
That’s ridiculous. It isn’t going to make it HEALTHY. look at everything else in there. That’s like putting a bandaid on a bullet hole babe.
Lol, you have a point, but it would be healthier.
This looks totally irresistible! Thanks for linking up with What’s Cookin’ Wednesday!
Thank you so much Karly! Thanks for the link party!
This takes cookie dough to a whole new level. Super gorgeous and creative!!!
Thanks Heather!
This is to die for!!! I must make it, I LOVE LOVE LOVE CHOCOLATE! And CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE DOUGH!!! MMMMM! (Sry about the caps, I’m just so excited)
Haha, your caps are so excited, they are making me excited!
I ask Do you bake the cookie dought ? Let me know thanks.Ana
Hi Ana, since it doesn’t have eggs, you don’t need to bake the dough.
Have you tried this using store bought ice cream softened to add cookie dough?
I haven’t, but I don’t see why it wouldn’t work. You could even just melt down cookie dough ice cream.
I just finished dinner and I don’t have anything sweet in the house! Thanks a lot for making my mouth water and all I can do is look at your pictures!
Seriously, these desserts look absolutely amazing, especially the cookie dough pie! Thanks for a great post!
How could you ever be without something sweet?!
Thanks Bill!
This looks AMAZING! I’m not a huge fan of cream cheese though, so could I use ice cream and then soften it?
Yes, you can use regular ice cream
This looks delicious! I was wondering, on the crust, when it says 15-20 oreos. Is that with the cream added or just one individual cookie?
I leave the cream in the Oreos. It will mix right into the crumbs and actually helps hold everything together.